Upper Eyelid Surgery versus Lower Eyelid Surgery: Understanding the Differences

Author : Ann Mary | Published On : 19 Nov 2026

Depending on what changes you are seeing in your eyes, you may think you only need one type of surgery, however significant differences can occur in upper and lower eyelid ageing. As a result, the procedures for the upper and lower eyelids differ. Some people may be concerned with upper eyelid sagging, whereas others may be more concerned with lower puffiness or shadows. Understanding the differences between the two procedures can give you a clearer picture of what options you have, and allow you to have a more informed discussion with a qualified surgeon.

Changes in Upper & Lower Eyelids

As the skin around the eyes is very thin, we often begin to see signs of ageing in this area earlier than elsewhere on our bodies. Collagen and elastic in the skin reduce, causing skin laxity. The small muscles around the eyes also relax, and the fat pads around the eyeballs can shift and bulge.

These changes can be accelerated by genetics, UV exposure, smoking and regular rubbing of the eyes due to allergies. Due to physical differences in the upper and lower eyelids, the upper and lower eyelids often face different issues.

Upper Blepharoplasty

The most common issue seen in the upper eyelid is excess skin (often referred to as ‘hooding’), which causes the eyes to appear tired and may give a smaller, less defined eye appearance. Some people may also have a small bulge of fat in the inner corner of the upper lid which gives a puffy appearance.

Sagging skin in the upper eyelid can also cause practical issues. If the skin is sufficiently loose, it can reduce the upper visual field, making activities such as reading or driving tiring. In these cases, upper blepharoplasty may be considered as a medical treatment. Often a visual field test will be done to determine how much visual field is being lost.

 

Procedure

In an upper blepharoplasty, the surgeon will mark the desired area of skin to be removed with you sitting upright. Incisions are made into the natural crease of the lid. Excess skin is removed. If required, a thin section of muscle and/or a small amount of fat can also be removed or rearranged. The incision is carefully sutured with fine stitches. As this line falls within the natural fold of the eyelid, the resulting scar is usually very well hidden.

Please note that upper lid sagging is not always caused by the eyelid. Sagging eyebrows (ptosis) can cause upper lid drooping. In these cases, a brow lift may be discussed. Alternatively, if the eyelid is drooping due to weakness in the muscle that lifts it, then a different surgical correction is required.

Lower Blepharoplasty

In contrast to the upper eyelids, puffiness in the lower eyelids is a more common concern. Puffiness occurs in the lower eyelids due to the fat in this area bulging forwards. Some people may also get a hollow gap between the lower lid and cheek, crepey fine lines, and overall tired looking eyes that don’t improve with rest.

Usually, the lower eyelids do not cause issues with vision, therefore lower Eyelid Surgery is nearly always purely cosmetic. However, if there is significant lid laxity, comfort and tear drainage may be affected. These issues will be carefully assessed.

Procedure

There are 2 common methods of lower blepharoplasty. The transconjunctival method involves an incision behind the lid, and therefore leaves no external scarring. This method is often suitable for younger patients, or those with mainly puffiness due to fat build-up, and still elastic skin.

The subciliary method involves placing the incision just below the lower lashes. This allows loose skin and muscle to be corrected, as well as fat. This can be useful in those with more noticeable laxity. In many cases, fat can now be repositioned in the hollow below the eye, instead of completely removed. This creates a smoother transition to the cheek, and prevents a deflated look.

Recovery

Swelling, bruising and tightness will occur in both types of Eyelid Surgery in the first few weeks. Applying cold compresses and resting with your head raised will aid recovery. Upper eyelid recovery often happens a little faster, and many people can comfortably return to public settings around 10 days after having stitches removed.

However, lower lid recovery may take slightly longer. Swelling tends to settle below the eyes, and may take longer to reduce. As the lower eyelid provides support from below the eye, care is taken to ensure that it is in the correct position during healing. Either operation may cause temporary dryness, watery eyes and sensitivity to bright lights. These symptoms usually settle in a few weeks.

Outcomes

Outcomes from upper Eyelid Surgery are often long lasting, however as the brow and surrounding skin will continue to age naturally, changes may occur. Fat removal or repositioning in the lower eyelid often gives very long-lasting results, as fat is unlikely to return. However, final results can often be seen 3-6 months post op. To help maintain good outcomes, healthy lifestyle choices should be made such as wearing sunglasses, applying sun cream and avoiding smoking.

Should I have upper/lower/both?

This very much depends on what issues you are experiencing. Some people may only require one area of correction. If both areas are an issue, it may be beneficial to have both at the same time. Performing an upper and lower blepharoplasty together is often referred to as a 4 lid blepharoplasty. This means that only one recovery period is required, which some people may find convenient. However, some people prefer to have one area corrected, and consider correcting the other at a later date. In order to make the best decision for you, it is best to have a thorough consultation to examine your eyelids, brows and cheeks, and overall eye health.

Conclusion

Although both upper and lower Eyelid Surgery aim to give a more refreshed eye appearance, the concerns addressed and methods used are different. Likewise, the recovery may be slightly different. Knowing the differences in these procedures can help you ask more informed questions and have the right expectations. Regardless of what you decide to do, taking your time, and discussing your goals with a board certified surgeon will give you the best chance of making the right choice for you.