The Real Maintenance Cost of Owning a Used Mercedes vs. Audi (2025 Guide)

Author : kamadhenucarsindia Admin@123 | Published On : 16 Feb 2026

We hear it every day at our showroom in Ahmedabad.

A customer falls in love with a pristine BMW 5-Series. They love the drive, they love the price, and they are ready to sign. Then, a well-meaning uncle whispers in their ear:

“Are you crazy? One service will cost ₹1 Lakh! It’s a white elephant.”

And just like that, the fear sets in.

But is it true? Does a used luxury car really drain your bank account, or is this just an outdated myth from the early 2000s?

At Kamdhenu Cars, we believe in radical transparency. We don’t want you to buy a car and then be shocked by the first bill. So, let’s open the books. Here is the actual cost of maintaining a used Mercedes, BMW, or Audi in 2025—no sugarcoating.

1. The “A” Service vs. “B” Service (The Routine Stuff)

German cars don’t just have a “Service.” They generally alternate between a minor service (Service A) and a major service (Service B).

Service A (Once a Year / 10,000 km):

What it includes: Engine oil change (synthetic), oil filter, air filter check, fluid top-ups, and a general inspection.
Estimated Cost: ₹15,000 – ₹22,000.
- Reality Check: A top-end Toyota Fortuner service costs roughly ₹12,000. The difference isn’t as massive as you think.

Service B (Every 2 Years / 20,000 km):

What it includes: All of the above PLUS cabin filters, brake fluid change, fuel filter, and a deeper diagnostic scan.
Estimated Cost: ₹35,000 – ₹55,000.

The Verdict: If you budget ₹40,000 per year purely for routine servicing, you are safe.

2. Brand vs. Brand: Who is the Wallet-Breaker?

Not all Germans are built the same. Based on our workshop data in Ahmedabad, here is how they stack up.

Mercedes-Benz (The Reliable Tank):

Reliability: High. The C-Class and E-Class are built for abuse.
Pain Points: Electronics (sensors) and air suspension (in high-end models like S-Class/GLE).
Cost Tier: Moderate. Parts are widely available, keeping prices competitive.

BMW (The Athlete):

Reliability: Good engines, but sensitive cooling systems.
Pain Points: BMWs are driven hard. Expect faster wear on Brake Pads and Suspension Bushings. If you drive like a racer, you will pay like one.
Cost Tier: Slightly Higher (mainly due to wear-and-tear items).

Audi (The Complex Tech):

Reliability: Decent, but sensitive to rough roads.
Pain Points: Suspension components (Link rods, control arms) tend to get noisy on Ahmedabad’s speed breakers. DSG gearbox oil changes are critical and expensive.
Cost Tier: Moderate to High.

3. The “Wear & Tear” Reality (The Big Bills)

This is where the “Uncle” was partially right. When parts fail, they cost more than Maruti parts.

Here are the common replacements you will face over 3-5 years of ownership:

Brake Pads (Set of 4): ₹25,000 – ₹35,000. (vs. ₹4,000 for a Honda City).
Tyres (Set of 4): ₹60,000 – ₹90,000. (Run-flat tires on BMWs are expensive).
Battery (AGM Technology): ₹25,000 – ₹35,000. (These aren’t standard batteries; they power the start-stop systems).
Suspension Overhaul: ₹1.0 Lakh – ₹1.5 Lakhs (Usually needed after 80,000 km).

The Kamdhenu Solution:

When we certify a car, we check the life of these components. If the tires are at 20%, we replace them before selling to you. That saves you an immediate ₹60,000 expense.

4. The “Authorized” vs. “Independent” Hack

This is the secret to affordable luxury ownership.

The Authorized Service Center:

Great for warranty claims and resale value. But you pay a premium for the marble flooring and free coffee.

Hourly Labor Rate: High.
Parts Markup: High.

The Specialist Independent Garage:

Ahmedabad has some fantastic German-specialist workshops (many run by ex-Mercedes/BMW technicians).

The Savings: They use OEM parts (same brand, just no car logo on the box) and charge 50% less for labor.
The Strategy: Use the Authorized center for the yearly oil change (to keep the service history stamp). Use the Independent garage for brakes, suspension, and repairs.

Result: You cut your maintenance bill by 40% instantly.

5. The “Lemon” Factor

The most expensive car is a cheap car that wasn’t maintained.

If you buy a BMW 3-Series that missed its last three oil changes, the engine sludge will eventually kill the turbocharger.

Turbo Replacement Cost: ₹1.5 Lakhs+.
Routine Oil Change Cost: ₹18,000.

This is why Service History is non-negotiable. At Kamdhenu, if a car doesn’t have a verifiable history, we don’t touch it.

Conclusion: It’s Not a Bill, It’s a Subscription

Think of maintenance as a subscription fee for luxury.

You are paying roughly ₹5,000 – ₹7,000 per month (averaged annually) to drive a machine that offers world-class safety, status, and comfort.

Is that expensive?

Compare it to the depreciation loss of a new car (₹20,000+ per month).

The maintenance is actually the cheaper part of the equation!

Don’t let the fear of a ₹20,000 bill stop you from enjoying a ₹50 Lakh driving experience.

Related Articles

FAQs

Q1: What is the average luxury car maintenance cost in India?
Most owners spend ₹40,000–₹70,000 per year on routine servicing, excluding major wear-and-tear.

Q2: Is Mercedes cheaper to maintain than Audi?
Generally yes. Mercedes parts are more widely available, while Audi suspension and DSG servicing costs more.

Q3: Can independent garages reduce luxury car service costs?
Yes. Good German-specialist garages can cut maintenance bills by up to 40%.

Q4: What is the most expensive repair in used luxury cars?
Suspension overhauls and turbo failures are among the costliest if maintenance is neglected.