Options screener and the pricing relationship between calls and puts
Author : Vittika Ai | Published On : 18 Nov 2026
Two option contracts linked to the same Indian stock can display very different premiums. One call option appears expensive, while a put option with the same strike price and expiry looks comparatively inexpensive. At first glance, the difference might suggest that market participants strongly favour one direction.
An options screener helps traders organise derivative contracts according to premiums, strike prices, expiry dates and other market characteristics. Vittika provides Indian equity research capabilities that can support the examination of underlying companies.
However, option premiums cannot be interpreted independently. Calls and puts have mathematical pricing relationships, and understanding those connections can help investors distinguish meaningful observations from misleading comparisons.
Two contracts can tell one connected story
A call option and a put option linked to the same underlying security represent different contractual rights.
A call gives its buyer the right associated with purchasing the underlying asset at the specified strike price, while a put provides the corresponding right associated with selling it, subject to the contract's settlement provisions.
Their premiums depend on several factors, including the underlying price, strike price, remaining time and implied volatility.
Importantly, these contracts are not priced in complete isolation.
A recognised financial relationship called put-call parity connects European-style call and put prices with the underlying asset, financing assumptions and expected distributions.
This relationship does not guarantee that every observed quote will match a theoretical calculation exactly.
Instead, it provides a framework for understanding why premiums across related contracts should be examined together.
Matching strike prices is only the beginning
Imagine two hypothetical option contracts on the same NSE-listed company.
Both have identical strike prices and expiry dates, but one is a call and the other is a put.
A researcher might compare their premiums to investigate how the market is pricing different contractual exposures.
However, comparing contracts with different expiries introduces additional complications because time remaining affects their values.
Different strike prices also change the relationship between each contract and the underlying share price.
An options screener becomes more informative when users first establish which contracts are genuinely comparable.
The relevant comparison should use consistent underlying securities, contract specifications, observation times and pricing information.
Vittika can support research into the underlying company's fundamentals and historical market behaviour, while contract-specific comparisons require appropriate derivatives data.
A comparison that ignores these distinctions may produce conclusions that appear mathematically persuasive but lack a reliable foundation.
Why an apparent pricing difference may be misleading
Suppose a hypothetical call premium appears unusually high relative to a put with the same strike and expiry.
It would be premature to interpret the difference as evidence of an incorrect market price.
Several factors may influence the observation.
The last traded prices might have been recorded at different times. One contract could have limited liquidity, while the other has more active quotations.
Differences in bid-ask spreads may also affect the apparent relationship between premiums.
Furthermore, theoretical pricing comparisons depend on assumptions about financing costs, expected dividends and the timing of cash flows.
A stock options analysis should account for these considerations before describing a pricing relationship as unusual.
Even when theoretical calculations suggest a discrepancy, transaction costs and execution conditions may prevent the quoted difference from being practically meaningful.
The purpose of analysis is to understand the available evidence, not assume that every mathematical difference represents a trading opportunity.
Dividends and financing costs influence the relationship
Options linked to dividend-paying companies require additional attention.
An expected dividend can influence the relationship between call and put prices because shareholders and option holders do not necessarily receive the same cash flows.
The timing and expected amount of a distribution can therefore matter when evaluating theoretical option values.
Financing costs also influence pricing relationships because payments occurring at different times have different present values.
When using an options screener, investors should avoid comparing call and put premiums without considering these underlying assumptions.
Research through Vittika can provide company-level financial context, including information relevant to historical profitability and shareholder distributions.
However, historical dividends should not automatically be treated as confirmed future payments.
Corporate announcements and applicable contract terms remain important when assessing the information relevant to an option's pricing.
A displayed premium is not always an executable price
Option screeners often display last traded prices alongside bid and ask quotations.
These figures describe different market observations.
The last traded price records a completed transaction. The bid and ask represent available quotations at a particular moment, subject to changing market conditions.
For less liquid option contracts, the last traded price may become outdated while available quotations continue changing.
This can create apparent inconsistencies between related contracts.
Investors should also consider available market depth and the quantities associated with quoted prices.
A theoretical comparison using stale or inconsistent information may produce an unreliable result.
Vittika can contribute to broader equity research, but current derivatives quotations and contract-specific liquidity information need independent verification.
These considerations demonstrate why theoretical pricing relationships should not be confused with guaranteed execution outcomes.
Build a comparison record rather than chasing discrepancies
A practical research process begins by identifying the underlying company and selecting comparable call and put contracts.
The researcher can then document the strike price, expiry date, option premiums, observation timestamps and available bid-ask information.
Relevant assumptions about interest rates, expected dividends and settlement conventions should also be recorded.
The next step involves checking whether the observed premium relationship is consistent with the selected pricing framework.
If a discrepancy appears, the analysis should investigate data quality, liquidity and calculation assumptions before reaching conclusions.
This approach has clear limitations.
Pricing models depend on assumptions, market conditions can change quickly, and contract obligations vary across positions.
For Indian stock options, investors must also understand applicable physical settlement requirements and other exchange rules.
A well-organised comparison can improve financial understanding, but it cannot eliminate uncertainty or guarantee a profitable transaction.
Conclusion
An options screener offers more than a way to identify contracts with unusual premiums or trading activity.
When calls and puts are examined together, investors can better understand how strike prices, expiry dates, financing costs and expected dividends influence option valuations.
However, theoretical relationships must be evaluated alongside liquidity, quotation quality and contract-specific risks.
The objective is not to identify supposedly mispriced contracts automatically, but to develop a clearer understanding of how related derivative instruments are valued.
Careful comparisons and consistent assumptions can make options research more informative without treating mathematical models as predictions of future market outcomes.
This content is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice. Investors should conduct their own research before making investment decisions.
