What’s the best color to replace Carmine

Author : santa color | Published On : 24 Sep 2021

To introduce you to the topic, carmine, also commonly known as cochineal, is a natural food colour that is drawn out from the structure of female insects. The insects red in property, gives out red pigments when taken out. According to studies, these types of insects can be frequently found in Latin America, a part of the country which constitutes several other regions. But are we aware of the fact that what can be used in place of carmine? Let us give you a detailed discussion about it.

Why substitutes?

As human beings are sensible enough to consume certified products, i.e., approved from the food authority. The said food colour, possessing this distinct feature of extraction from an insect, is not consider safe to eat. Thus, the manufacturers need to seek for different alternatives that can be used instead of cochineal.


In simplest terms, anthocyanins are pigments that can be examined in natural products, the fruits and vegetables. They typically portray red, purple, or blue shades, directly linked with their pH (Power of hydrogen). In this contemporary world, some of the common edibles that have anthocyanins are blackberries, blueberries, and cherries.

After giving heat to the dye, the dye preserves its red colour, therefore, making it a stable alternative to cochineal.


Monascus is basically a classification of yeast, particularly the red yeast, use quite often in countries like Japan and China; red yeast is broke down into smaller substances, and that’s what exactly is monascus. It’s red-coloured characteristic makes it feasible for use in place of carmine; monascus is generally include in edibles like meat, ice-cream, rice, beverages, ketchups, etc. The Chinese are the most familiar with this pigment, according to researches carried out.

They are safe for consumption, don’t carry with them adverse effects on health, and should be used by the producers in lieu of the carmine.


For those of you who might not know what paprika is, it is a food spice compose of red chillies; the red chillies are broke down until it becomes powder. The said powder is paprika. It’s dark orange to red property can be a perfect competitor to carmine. Surprisingly, the spice also contains health benefits; capsaicin is a compound that has antioxidation property – combats several types of cancers, boosts immunity, and aids in the personal well-being of an individual.

It’s widely use for topping on consumptions like rice, vegetables, and meat. The spice can be cost-effective for the manufacturers in the long run, and so, they should take up this and remove cochineal.


Beets are vegetables that are often a part of salad. They’re dark-pink to slight-red aspect aims at replacing the pigment mentioned at the very start. They’re available on beet plants. They can attain to the pH level as that of the carmine, making them viable for use in yoghurts and dairy products, which includes milk and cheese. Beet is cost-effective, holds numerous health benefits, and has a great sunlight stability.